14 June 2024 | 12:56 AM

A multi-billion rand programme yet no protective clothing

Key Takeaways

Scores of Community Work Programme (CWP) workers in the Eastern Cape have not been provided with adequate protective clothing. Many are clad in sandals and use their bare hands to work in often hazardous terrain surrounding schools and community facilities. Some even lack the tools to do the job.

However, few complain as they labour under the threat that they could lose their jobs. Many are afraid to report adverse working conditions, fearing they will end up losing the R750 they earn in a month – often their only income.

The CWP is funded by the department of cooperative governance and traditional affairs and is run throughout the country. The programme, run in the province by two non-profits, the Southern African Youth Movement (SAYM) and Thembalethu Development, enables unemployed people to learn new skills and earn income to help feed their families.

CWP workers are employed for about eight days a month except in November and December, when they work for 10 days and earn R910.

The Daily Dispatch visited a number of sites throughout the Eastern Cape where the programme is being run by SAYM and spoke to some of the workers.

Those who we interviewed were mostly employed to do gardening, including planting vegetables at schools and in townships. They continue working no matter the weather but lack the right clothing and tools.

The clothing they showed us was marked “Smart Safety” and “Pro-Drill 333”. It had proven not durable in the conditions under which the workers laboured. They said the clothing tore within three months and their safety shoes had developed holes and cracked soles.

Smart Safety did not reply to questions by the time of going to press and we were unable to contact Pro-Drill 333.

All the workers who spoke to us opted to remain anonymous, saying this was because of previous threats from SAYM project managers. As Cogta’s implementing agent, the SAYM provides protective gear and tools, and pays salaries to those who are on the programme in the province.

“I have worked on this project for more than three years and I was happy. But the protective gear that we’ve got recently is made of cheap material which you cannot even wear for months. It tears easily,” said a woman in Cala.

She said that the eight days they worked per month were not enough.

“If they are buying us this cheap uniform, the money that they are saving (on buying better protective gear)) should come to us. We should be getting warm jackets and proper working gear,” she said.

A supervisor at the same site said they were struggling to get tools and had resorted to using tools belonging to a local school.

“If the school is closed, we don’t get tools to work. We are constantly in a struggle to get things right here. The problem is that we are being threatened if we complain,” said the supervisor.

At a site in Port Elizabeth, we found workers wearing broken safety shoes. They showed us that their new “plastic-like” safety shoes were splitting although they were only six months old.

“There’s an issue here where the workers are not catered for. We are struggling with the little money we earn and then the issue of the protective clothing we get. The clothes are not durable, not safe at all.

“Whoever is manufacturing this clothing is not doing a good job, these are cheap clothes and yet government pumps millions of rands into this project,” a worker said.

A worker in Kirkwood said they’d been threatened with losing their jobs if they complained about anything.

“We have been in this situation for many years now. I complained that I don’t have proper shoes and I was using my only shoes but I was told to shut up, or I would be fired,” he said.

He mentioned two officials who had allegedly threatened to act against those who complained.

Attempts to get a comment from SAYM drew a blank. Email, text messages and WhatsApp messages were sent to SAYM spokesperson Boikhutso Masipa but there was no response at the time of publication.

Also read

Who’s eating Cogta’s R13bn Community Works Programme?

Cogta “asked SSA” to investigate journalist

Who’s eating the Community Work Programme? Explore the data

*This article is part of an ongoing investigation into the CWP by Daily Dispatch and the amaBhungane Centre for Investigative Journalism. For more keep reading Daily Dispatch or go to

*Photos: Michael Pinyana (Daily Dispatch)

Share this story:




Before joining the amaBhungane team in 2017, Micah was the national coordinator for media freedom and diversity at the Right2Know Campaign. He holds a Masters in African Studies from Oxford University and a BA Honours in History from Wits University.

Your identity is safe with us. Email or Call us


Related Stories